I was at the Seattle Founders Institute graduation event last night with 40 others who gathered to see the 3 newly minted entrepreneurs from the program. From the over 100’s of applicants, there were 30+ who signed up for the program, and yesterday 3 folks graduated.
TeaBook is a monthly tea subscription. The founder has spent a lot of time in China to source and obtain unique tea’s that will be mailed to your home every day. The tea market is over $25 Billion and growing at 7% annually. They had a great story and compelling market presence. I personally felt the monthly subscription commerce business has many players, and I suspect in the next few years there will be much consolidation. The tea market itself has many competitors as well including TeaLet, teabox, Chahoney and LizzyKate. They have some early indication of traction, with some trials and some passionate customers already willing to sign up for the service.
American Giving – was focused on ending poverty in the US, with a researched philanthropy website. They founder was looking to create a indegogo style site, where philanthropists could research, back and support giving to Americans better. The potential to unlock over a $ Trillion in well researched giving would be large and they were looking to take a 15% admission fee on all giving.
MeltingSpot, has a 2 sided marketplace for helping consumers looking to meet “folks they like” near them. Think of “Tinder meets FourSquare”. They Melting Spot could be a bar, or a restaurant, who wants to “sponsor” a spot where people only interested in “animals” would be able to meet others. There are many dating sites and apps, and many social networks, but their focus was on helping folks in their local region. They would make money by charging bars to sponsor a “melting spot” – initial suggested retail price was $30/month.
All 3 entrepreneurs had great stories and did an excellent job showcasing the market (which was large) and spoke to their personal backgrounds as well. None of them had a working website or prototype (some mockups), but they had financial projections. They were all non developer or technical founders, looking for their CTO, but had the sales and marketing background and expertise.
All of them were looking to raise some money – from early seed (>$100K) to seed ($2 Million – teabook).
As an investor, the biggest challenge I faced was I was not sure how many more pivots were going to happen before they get Product Market fit. I suspect a lot more, because none of them had product shipping yet.
Which leads me believe that Kickstarter or Indegogo is the best way to show social proof, customer validation and early traction.
If you have an idea and you want to progress on the journey towards investment, the launch page with social proof, early orders on your crowd funding campaign, product prototype and having a well rounded team are a must have for #napkinStage companies. Those would be the things to focus on, more than distribution channels,